How Netflix Forgot To Love Its Core Customers

Netflix is bigger than ever, yet its subscribers are watching less. Joan Kiddon on why chasing new customers while neglecting loyal ones is brand mismanagement.
Joan KiddonNovember 16, 20267 min

Political commentators and observers repeatedly point to the engagement of voters in the recent midterm elections. Engagement, or commitment, is as critical for product and service brands as it is for political candidate brands. Without committed – engaged – customers, success – quality revenue growth – becomes less attainable.

Do not assume that because a brand is big, it is big in customers’ minds. Just ask Netflix.

It is comical, but sad, that we are hearing again about the lack of commitment – engagement – on the part of Netflix customers. Yes, Netflix has millions of subscribers. Netflix is BIG. The problem is that Netflix customers do not watch Netflix as much as they used to. Netflix customers’ lessening interest in Netflix affects Netflix’s financial base. Why? Because Netflix has offerings with advertising. Advertisers want eyeballs. Less Netflix customer commitment means Netflix is not delivering eyeballs to its advertisers. Plus, content costs money to make – or buy, as with sports. The fewer the viewers, the less the positive word-of-mouth and the greater the monetary loss associated with making and advertising that content.

This article is part of Branding Strategy Insider’s FREE newsletter. Join the world’s smartest marketers and subscribe here for actionable insights delivered directly to your inbox.

A Lesson Netflix Did Not Learn

In 2022, four years ago, Netflix faced the same core customer problem. At the time, the investment community tepidly recommended that Netflix focus on “engaging” current customers rather than focusing only on scavenging for new customers. But then, Netflix showed larger and larger numbers of new subscribers. More subscribers, more subscription fees, more money. The investment community stopped suggesting that Netflix strengthen the commitment of its core customer base. Follow the money, as always.

The Wall Street Journal recently described the 2022 crisis as follows:

“Netflix has dealt with slumps before. When it lost subscribers in 2022, it introduced a cheaper plan with commercials and cracked down on password sharing. The plan worked, and the stock came roaring back. With its price-to-forward-earnings multiple now back to its 2022 lows, bulls see a cheap stock and are expecting Netflix to find new levers to pull.”

Well, business as usual, so here we are again. We are back to the future. Netflix is still big – bigger than before. But the current customer base is less “engaged” with the brand. Netflix did not learn any lessons from 2022. Netflix ignored one of the fundamental principles of branding, making one of marketing’s biggest mistakes. The principle is simple: Love your core customer.

The Scavenger Brand

Netflix’s strategy has been to scavenge for new customers. Scavenger brands focus on growth by acquisition of new customers. Netflix is a voracious vulture for viewership while it takes its current customers for granted. Netflix is the conquistador of streaming.

Netflix thinks it is a different kind of brand owning a different marketplace. Netflix acts as if a streaming, digital entity can forget the rules of brand management for enduring, profitable growth. No, Netflix is a brand. There are certain principles that brands must follow to be enduring and profitable while growing. After decades in brand management, it is extremely frustrating that brands with the best people do such damaging things to their brands. Ignoring the core customer is brand mismanagement. Ignoring the current customer is brand suicide. Netflix is a brand: brand management IS business management and vice versa.

Wall Street Is The Enabler

Netflix lusts after the customers it does not have more than it loves the customers it does have. Netflix focuses on growth only by attracting new customers. Wall Street is the enabler. Wall Street penalizes Netflix if new customer counts are too low. On the other hand, by rewarding Netflix for new subscriber numbers only, Wall Street is effectively penalizing shareholder gains. The Wall Street financial wunderkinds are shooting themselves in the foot. Wake up, Wall Street: there is no shareholder value if there is no customer-perceived brand value. If your current customers are bored, forget about shareholder returns. Wall Street wants growth, but Wall Street also wants profit. To have both performance and profit, a brand must attract and retain customers. Netflix is attracting new customers but providing limited reasons for current customers to stay engaged.

Current customers must be retained, respected and loved. Brand-loyal customers are a brand’s most valuable assets. Brand-loyal customers are less price sensitive; they are less willing to abandon your brand for a competitive brand; they are more forgiving when the brand makes a mistake; and they are more willing to consider new products and services from the brand they love.

Subscribed, But Not Watching

In 2022, as a Netflix subscriber, you may have watched most of the content for which you signed up. You may have canceled and/or moved on to the next shiny new streaming service. This behavior is what one analyst described as: “(Customers) come in… watch… cancel and… go.” Where is the additional value for the subscriber to stay loyal?

Yet today, millions of Netflix subscribers are not moving on. Netflix customers are keeping their subscriptions – for now – but they are in a Netflix miasma of experiential ennui. Customers are keeping their subscriptions, but customers are just not watching as frequently. According to Barron’s, subscribers are opening the Netflix app less frequently, “… on fewer days each month than they did a few years ago.” When customers do open the app, they are spending less time watching; “… average viewing time” has declined. Bloomberg, citing the app tracker Apptopia, reports that the share of U.S. subscribers who did not open the app at all rose 16.6% in the third quarter compared with a year earlier. The bottom line of any Plan to Win is more customers, who use more frequently, who are more loyal, generating more revenue, leading to enduring profitable growth. Netflix needs to reinforce customer attachment.

Is your brand chasing new customers while the ones you have drift away? The Plan to Win is the one-page method behind iconic turnarounds: it aligns every leader on which customers matter most, what you promise them and how you will keep them. In a 20-minute call, we’ll tell you whether it is the right move for your business.

Give Customers More Reasons To Stay

The recent business press indicates that the way Netflix will improve “engagement” is with new, view-worthy content. Of course. Customers sign up for content. But there is more to keeping customers engaged with a brand. Netflix should be offering a wide variety of Netflix-branded experiences for current users.

TCM, the channel offering classic, mostly vintage movies, has a magazine, a cruise and a wine club. There is also an opportunity for special “fans” to select their favorite movie and be on air when the movie airs.

The Wall Street Journal, with WSJ+, provides events, promotions and experience packages that include trips, discussions, free audiobooks, educational courses, cooking classes, virtual tours and passes for galleries. There is a wine club, as well. The Wall Street Journal focuses on finding new readers to subscribe while ensuring that current readers have an expanded Wall Street Journal experience beyond newsprint.

Samsung phones offer customers a quality, exciting experience that will positively influence their future purchases of Samsung appliances. Samsung understands that some customers are not yet appliance buyers. However, it is worthwhile keeping these future appliance customers in the Samsung franchise.

Each of these brands gives its current customers more reasons to stay. Netflix mostly gives them more titles.

From Disrupter To Disrupted

Netflix is such a sorry business case. For an entertainment brand, Netflix is rather cheerless. Once, Netflix was the brave, innovative pioneer. Netflix was the category definer. It was the disrupter, and now it is being disrupted. The Wall Street Journal reported on one analyst’s opinion:

“The bigger problem, says Needham analyst Laura Martin, is that Netflix still makes nearly all its money from a single business that has matured. Traditional media giants squeeze a hit through theaters, merchandise, theme parks, and licensing. Netflix mostly just streams it. And she [the analyst] warns that artificial intelligence will let YouTube’s creators make better, longer videos for the same money, bringing them closer to competing with Netflix’s own.”

Netflix’s history appears to be on rewind, a Groundhog Day of its own making. Is it possible that Netflix will start to respect and implement proper brand management for this stellar, pioneering brand? Or will Netflix continue to take its existing customer base for granted? If the latter is true, Netflix will be the poster child for the old saying: “Pioneers are those with the arrows in their backs.”

Contributed to Branding Strategy Insider by Joan Kiddon, Partner, The Blake Project, author of The Paradox Planet: Creating Brand Experiences For The Age Of I.

At The Blake Project, we help leaders turn brand into a disciplined driver of financial performance — strengthening pricing power, competitive position, and enterprise value. Email us to start a conversation about enduring profitable growth. For The EBITDA.

Joan Kiddon

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Connect With Us

footer-logo

Branding Strategy Insider is published by The Blake Project, an independently owned, strategic brand consultancy with extensive experience helping businesses and brands gain an emotional advantage, a distinctive advantage and a connective advantage.

Subscribe and Grow

Choose how often you receive our insights.


© 2026 Branding Strategy Insider. All Rights Reserved.